Elisha v Vision Australia Limited

[2024] HCA 50
Judgment date
Case number
M22/2024
Before
Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson, Jagot, Beech-Jones JJ
Catchwords

Damages – Assessment – Breach of contract – Scope of contractual duty – Remoteness – Where appellant employed by respondent – Where incident involving appellant occurred during travel for appellant's work duties – Where appellant provided with "stand down letter" outlining allegations arising from incident – Where previous reports of appellant's aggressive behaviour – Where disciplinary meeting held for appellant to respond to allegations in stand down letter – Where employment terminated – Where decision to terminate employment based upon allegations of previous aggressive behaviour not put to appellant contrary to respondent's disciplinary procedure – Where appellant diagnosed with major depressive disorder – Whether liability for psychiatric injury caused by employer's breach beyond scope of employer's duty concerned with manner of dismissal – Whether rule in Addis v Gramophone Company Ltd [1909] AC 488 precludes recovery of damages for breach of contract in respect of psychiatric injury caused by manner of dismissal – Whether damage too remote.

Contract – Incorporation of terms – Employment contracts – Policies and procedures – Where employer's disciplinary procedure in enterprise agreement and policy document – Where contract of employment required employee to agree to comply with employer's policies and procedures – Whether disciplinary procedure incorporated as term of employment contract.

Negligence – Duty of care – Whether employers owe duty to employees to provide safe system of investigation and decision-making with respect to discipline and termination of employment.

Words and phrases – "common intention of the parties", "duty of care", "general manner in which the damage occurred", "general type of damage", "incorporation", "manner of dismissal", "mental distress", "on the cards", "psychiatric injury", "reasonable contemplation of the parties", "remoteness of damage", "safe system of work", "scope of contractual duty", "serious possibility", "willing to accept".

Files
50.docx (123.62 KB)
50.pdf (412.25 KB)