Crime and Corruption Commission v. Carne
Case No.
B66/2022
Case Information
Lower Court Judgment
05/08/2022 Supreme Court of Queensland (Court of Appeal) (Mullins & McMurdo JJA, Freeburn J)
Catchwords
Constitutional law – Legislature – Privileges – Privilege of parliamentary debate and proceedings – Where Crime and Corruption Commission ("Commission") received complaint as to allegations of corrupt conduct against respondent, former Public Trustee of Queensland – Where, following investigation, Commission prepared draft report, which did not make any finding of corrupt conduct – Where Commission submitted copy of Report to Chair of Parliamentary Crime and Corruption Committee ("PCCC") and requested, pursuant to s 69(1)(b) of Crime and Corruption Act 2001 (Qld) ("CC Act"), that it be given to Speaker – Where respondent filed originating application seeking declaration that report was not "report" for purposes of s 69(1) of CC Act – Where Chair of PCCC issued evidentiary certificate under s 55 of Parliament of Queensland Act 2001 (Qld) ("POQ Act") certifying report as: document prepared for purpose of, or incidental to, transacting business of PCCC under s 9(2)(c) of CC Act; and document present or submitted to PCCC – Where s 8(1) of POQ Act provides proceedings in Assembly cannot be impeached or questioned in any court – Whether parliamentary privilege protects reports prepared for and provided to parliamentary committees under POQ Act.
Statutes – Acts of Parliament – Interpretation – Where s 33 of CC Act provides for Commission's corruption functions – Where s 64 of CC Act provides Commission may report in performing its functions – Where s 69(1) provides report may be tabled in Parliament when report is made on a public hearing or report is directed to be given to Speaker – Where respondent contended that because report did not make finding of "corrupt conduct" and did not relate to public hearing, it was not report for purposes of s 69 of CC Act – Whether Commission only able to report about corruption investigation under CC Act where positive finding of "corrupt conduct".
Documents*
15/12/2022 Hearing (SLA, Canberra)
23/12/2022 Notice of appeal
02/02/2023 Written submissions (Appellant)
02/02/2023 Chronology (Appellant)
24/02/2023 Written submissions (Attorney-General of the Commonwealth of Australia, seeking leave to intervene)
24/02/2023 Written submissions (Speaker of the Legislative Assembly of Queensland, seeking leave to intervene)
10/03/2023 Written submissions (Respondent)
30/03/2023 Reply (Attorney-General of the Commonwealth of Australia, seeking leave to intervene)
31/03/2023 Reply (Appellant)
06/06/2023 Hearing (Full Court, Canberra) (Audio-visual recording)
06/06/2023 Outline of oral argument (Appellant)
06/06/2023 Outline of oral argument (Respondent)
06/06/2023 Outline of oral argument (Attorney-General of the Commonwealth of Australia, intervening)
05/06/2023 Outline of oral argument (Speaker of the Legislative Assembly of Queensland, intervening)
07/06/2023 Hearing (Full Court, Canberra) (Audio-visual recording)
13/09/2023 Judgment (Judgment summary)